Thursday, September 21, 2017

No. CLX: Wither We Ghost

Guardian: Were we happier in the stone age?


...From the viewpoint of individual happiness, the "agricultural revolution" was, in the words of the scientist Jared Diamond, "the worst mistake in the history of the human race".

...Evolution has no interest in happiness per se: it is interested only in survival and reproduction...Evolution makes sure that no matter what we achieve, we remain dissatisfied, forever grasping for more.

For two thousand centuries (current best guess)
we hunted and gathered with minimum stress.
We thrived. Some did. (Well, more or less.)

We settled down. We started farming.
Turning wolves into to dogs, I suppose, was thought charming.
Chopping trees, draining bogs we start global warming.

At most, we've been “civilized” (maybe) twelve thousand years.
Our numbers have grown. (Along with our fears.)
Have we advanced? Are we more in arrears?

“Civilization”, I guess, has made a mess.
We created a rat race to pursue happiness
and thus far we've not had that much success.

Some say “compete”, others say “share”.
And then they argue about which is fair.
Forget happiness. Let us despair.

If what we're pursuin'
leads to our ruin,
it 's all our own doin'.

See also: New Yorker: The Case Against Civilization


...the agricultural revolution was, for most of the people living through it, a disaster. The fossil record shows that life for agriculturalists was harder than it had been for hunter-gatherers. Their bones show evidence of dietary stress: they were shorter, they were sicker, their mortality rates were higher. Living in close proximity to domesticated animals led to diseases that crossed the species barrier, wreaking havoc in the densely settled communities....Jared Diamond called the Neolithic Revolution “the worst mistake in human history.” The startling thing about this claim is that, among historians of the era, it isn’t very controversial.